Skip to content

Why AI fails and how to avoid common mistakes

UPADI · Published · 8 sources

Direct answer: AI in India succeeds in about 32 to 35% of cases (Lok Sabha, March 2025). Failure has many causes: "improper timing of insemination, problems with semen storage, poor artificial insemination (A.I.) technique, embryonic death, infection, heat stress, metabolic issues" and the cow not ovulating (Penn State Extension, via Progressive Dairy). The first three are in the technician's hands, and they are the subject of this page.

Mistakes in the technician's control

Straw storage and removal

Mistake Why it matters Do this instead
Letting the LN2 level fall below the straws Semen warms and dies Keep LN2 above straw level; measure 35 L cans weekly (DAHD SoP)
Lifting the canister above the frost line Mini straws suffer "irreversible damage" with even 10 seconds' exposure (NDDB) Raise only as high as needed; remove within 10 seconds (DAHD SoP)
Searching for a straw with the canister up Every straw in that canister is exposed, not only the one you take Keep an inventory and tag canisters (DAHD SoP); if time runs out, lower the canister and try again (UW Madison)
Picking straws with fingers Fingertips are a heat source (UW Madison) Use forceps, cooled first (DAHD SoP)
Carrying straws in a pocket, flask or bag of water or ice Forbidden by the SoP Carry doses in the cryocan to the farmer's door (DAHD SoP)

Thawing

Mistake Do this instead
Guessing the water temperature Use a thermometer and set 37 °C (DAHD SoP)
Thawing too short, too long or upright 40 to 45 seconds, horizontal (DAHD SoP)
Thawing several straws stuck together They thaw unevenly; keep them apart (UW Madison)
Thawing more doses than you can use soon Thaw only what you can inseminate in 10 to 15 minutes (Minitube)
Leaving the thawed straw wet Wipe it dry before loading (DAHD SoP)
Waiting after thawing Inseminate as early as possible (DAHD SoP)

Gun and sheath

Mistake Do this instead
Cold gun in winter Keep the gun and sheath near 37 °C (DAHD SoP)
Slanted or crushed cut Cut at a right angle just below the laboratory seal with sharp scissors (DAHD SoP)
Air bubble at the wrong end Check it is at the laboratory seal end before loading (DAHD SoP)
Loose or poor quality sheath Semen can leak back inside the sheath and be lost (Minitube); lock it firmly with the O ring
Cleaning with surgical spirit or soap "Lethal to semen"; use water, hot water and isopropyl alcohol as the SoP says

More in the AI gun and sheath guide.

Timing

  • Too early is common in buffaloes. In an Indian field study no buffalo conceived when inseminated within 10 hours of heat signs; the best result was at 23 to 26 hours (Srivastava and others, 1998).
  • Too late is risky in cows: conception in the same study fell after 14 hours, and none conceived at 31 to 48 hours.
  • Missed or silent heat. Failure to detect heat and weak or silent heat are among the reasons TANUVAS lists for animals not being bred (Vikaspedia).

See heat signs and AI timing.

Technique

  • Insemination before a rectal examination. The SoP asks for it before preparing the gun (DAHD SoP).
  • Contaminated tip. Never let it touch the coat, anus or vulva.
  • Wrong site. Deposit just outside the internal os, slowly over about 5 seconds.
  • Force. Blood on the tip or glove means too much force. If the animal moves, stop.

All from the DAHD SoP.

Causes that need a veterinarian

Some failures have nothing to do with the straw:

Cause What the source says
Illness after calving Cows with a disorder between calving and AI were 7 to 10% less likely to conceive (Penn State, via Progressive Dairy)
Not ovulating Anovulation persists in at least 20% of dairy cows beyond 60 days after calving (same source)
Early embryo loss More than 20% of embryos do not survive beyond four weeks; another 12% are lost between day 28 and day 60 (same source)
Nutrition Lack of energy, protein, minerals and vitamin A (TANUVAS, via Vikaspedia)
Infection Diseases such as brucellosis and IBR can cause early embryonic death (same TANUVAS page)
Heat stress Seek effective heat relief in hot months (Penn State, via Progressive Dairy)

TANUVAS calls an animal that has not conceived after more than three services a repeat breeder (Vikaspedia). Refer such animals to a veterinarian rather than inseminating again and again.

A quick self check

  1. Is the LN2 level in my can above the straws today?
  2. Did I use a thermometer for this thaw?
  3. Did I take the straw out in under 10 seconds with cooled forceps?
  4. Was the gun warm and the cut straight?
  5. Was the animal in a clear heat, at the right hour?
  6. Did I record the AI on Bharat Pashudhan?

Diagnosis and treatment of infertility are for your veterinarian.

Questions and answers

Why does artificial insemination fail?

Causes include wrong timing, poor semen storage, thawing or handling, poor AI technique, the animal not ovulating, early embryo loss, infection, heat stress and poor nutrition. The handling and timing causes are in the technician's control.

What is the most common straw handling mistake?

Lifting the canister above the frost line or keeping it in the neck too long while searching for a straw. The DAHD SoP limits removal to 10 seconds, and NDDB warns mini straws are harmed by even 10 seconds above the nitrogen.

What is a repeat breeder?

TANUVAS describes an animal that has not conceived after more than three services as a repeat breeder. It needs a veterinarian's examination, not just another AI.

Sources

  1. Standard operating procedures for Artificial Insemination Technicians / MAITRIs (OM dated 24 January 2026), Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairying, Government of India (hosted by Odisha DAHVS) (accessed 2026-11-19)
  2. Lok Sabha Unstarred Question 1898, Artificial Insemination (11 March 2025), archived copy, Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairying, Government of India (accessed 2026-11-19)
  3. Why cows don't get pregnant (Andrew Sandeen, Penn State Extension), Progressive Dairy (accessed 2026-11-19)
  4. Breeding Management (from Expert System for Cattle and Buffalo, TANUVAS), Vikaspedia, Government of India (accessed 2026-11-19)
  5. Manual on Semen Production (Minimum Standards for Production of Bovine Frozen Semen), National Dairy Development Board (accessed 2026-11-19)
  6. Proper semen handling for improved fertility in bovines and other livestock, University of Wisconsin Madison Division of Extension (accessed 2026-11-19)
  7. Technical cornerstones of successful AI in cattle, Minitube (accessed 2026-11-19)
  8. Time of insemination and conception in cows and buffaloes under field condition (Srivastava SK, Sahni KL, Mohan G), Indian Journal of Animal Sciences 68(2), 1998, ICAR (accessed 2026-11-19)

Products in this article

All UPADI Knowledge articles